Op-Ed: Is This Fair? Balatro Hit With 18+ Age Rating Change

Copy link Share on Twitter Share on Facebook

Mar 05, 2024 5 min read

A bunch of us here at PokerNews have been absolutely enamoured and hooked by the sensational 'poker, rogue-lite' game Balatro. I, for one, have pushed back several bedtimes to do "just one more" run (it's never just one), and I know for a fact that my colleagues have done the same, whether they admit to it or not.

We're not the only ones experiencing Balatro-induced panda eyes, either. The game has been a huge hit across various platforms, with over 250,000 copies sold in its opening three days. Many fans say they can't stop playing it. But our favorite 'poker not poker game' has been in the headlines for different reasons.

Various gamers outside of the Americas discovered that the game had disappeared from the Nintendo Switch eShop while Balatro was also hit with an 18+ Pegi rating due to displaying prominent gambling imagery. Is this fair? I don't think it is, and I will try and explain why, but first, I will lay out what's taken place over the last few days.

Playstack Issues Statement

When PokerNews first wrote about Balatro, its age rating was 3+, but this has since changed to 18+, and video game company Playstack took to X to address the situation.

"We are that Balatro has been temporarily removed from sale on a number of digital stores in some countries on console platforms, meaning that some new customers will be unable to buy it," Playstack said. "Presently, we cannot estimate with complete confidence which stores it will be removed from."

��This is not an issue with the stores themselves, however a reaction to an overnight change to Balatro��s age rating from 3+ to 18+ by a ratings board without any advance warning due to a mistaken belief that the game ��contains prominent gambling imagery and material that instructs about gambling.��"

Then, on March 4, Playstack posted another update on what platforms have and have not been affected by the age rating change. Thankfully, the game is still available on most platforms, with only Nintendo users having some difficulties accessing it.

"Following further analysis, we can now confirm that changes to Balatro��s age rating has affected only one platform in limited regions. We expect to be back up everywhere later this week."

When is Gambling, Gambling?

Users can't gamble on Balatro for real money; it's simply a game where the goal is to make poker hands from the in-game deck of cards. Does that mean the Solitaire you find pre-loaded on old Windows computers should be rebranded as 18+ because gambling imagery, a deck of cards in this case, is used?

Then obviously, there's the wider debate around loot boxes in titles such as EA FC, where kids can freely spend $X in the hopes of packing a Lionel Messi or Neymar for example. Surely, that mechanic is more akin to gambling than anything presented by Balatro? Especially when the latter has no in-game microtransactions. Once you pay the $15 to buy the game, that's the only money a user spends. Furthermore, you're competing against the computer/AI; you're not even playing other people.

The age rating fiasco is something that the developers thought had been ironed out before the game's release. In October, Playstack successfully overturned an original 18+ rating during an appeal where the ratings board said "we have reviewed your product and determined that the disclosure of gambling these was unwarranted."

No content changes have been made to the game since it was changed to 3+, so this current decision appears extremely harsh. The sole developer behind the game, @localthunk, also responded to the news in a social media post, which caught the eye of streamer and poker player Ludwig, who uploaded a YouTube video in defence of his "favorite game."

Ludwig's and my sentiments are very similar, and the former also raises valid points regarding the game of chance elements in Balatro. Ludwig, like myself, doesn't consider Solitaire a gambling game. While we both agree there are threads of luck involved when playing both games, that's just due to "randomness."

Additionally, while the hand ranking system is clearly influenced by poker, there are some hands you can play in the game that are just not possible in poker, such as five of a kind, where you can use the same suit. Don't believe me? Check out our poker rules page!

The age-rating change has also had a knock-on effect for content creators. Balatro videos have been taken down and demonetized, which, in my opinion, is just ludicrous. Again, where is the promotion of gambling? Money is being taken out of working people's pockets due to a misunderstanding, and one that had originally been rectified.

Maybe everything will be resolved over the coming days or weeks, meaning this just becomes another rambling on the internet. But for now, the decision to make Balatro 18+ due to perceived gambling elements is farcical.

Calum has been a part of the PokerNews team since September 2021 after working in the UK energy sector. He played his first hand of poker in 2017 and immediately fell in love with the game. Calum has written for various poker outlets but found his home at PokerNews, where he has contributed to various articles and live updates, providing insights and reporting on major poker events, including the World Series of Poker (WSOP).

Follow on

• Tags Balatro